100% match
1. SOMA
2015 · $29.99 · 95% positive
Horror Exploration Lovecraftian Puzzle
Why it's similar: SOMA shares Amnesia: Rebirth's focus on horror, exploration and lovecraftian.
How it differs: The big change is the setting: underwater and sci fi. It is a 2015 release, older than Amnesia: Rebirth.
Best pick if horror is what kept you playing Amnesia: Rebirth.