100% match
1. Cookie Clicker
2021 · $4.99 · 96% positive
Incremental Idler Management Economy
Why it's similar: Cookie Clicker scratches the same itch as Budgie's Bug Shop: incremental, idler and management.
How it differs: It swaps the setting for horror. It is an older game from 2021.
Best pick if incremental is what kept you playing Budgie's Bug Shop.