100% match
1. Amnesia: The Dark Descent
2010 · $19.99 · 95% positive
Horror Gore Psychological Horror Survival Horror
Why it's similar: Amnesia: The Dark Descent scratches the same itch as Butcher's Creek: horror, gore and psychological horror.
How it differs: It costs more ($19.99 vs $9.99). The big change is the setting: lovecraftian.
Start here if the horror in Butcher's Creek was your favorite part.