100% match
1. Sid Meier's Pirates!
2005 · $9.99 · 94% positive
Pirates Open World Naval Sailing
Why it's similar: Players tag Sid Meier's Pirates! with the same things they love in Caribbean Legend — pirates, open world and naval.
How it differs: At $9.99 it costs less than Caribbean Legend ($29.99). It is an older game from 2005.
Best pick if pirates is what kept you playing Caribbean Legend.