100% match
1. Terraria
2011 · $9.99 · 97% positive · Co-op
Sandbox Open World Survival Craft Survival Pixel Graphics
Why it's similar: Terraria shares Core Keeper's focus on sandbox, open world survival craft and survival.
How it differs: At $9.99 it costs less than Core Keeper ($19.99). It is a 2011 release, older than Core Keeper.
Best pick if sandbox is what kept you playing Core Keeper.