100% match
1. Dota 2
2013 · Free · 87% positive · Co-op
MOBA eSports Character Customization
Why it's similar: Dota 2 scratches the same itch as Eternal Return: moba, esports and character customization.
How it differs: Unlike Eternal Return, you can play it in co-op. It swaps the setting for fantasy.
Best pick if moba is what kept you playing Eternal Return.