100% match
1. Clicker Heroes
2015 · Free · 88% positive
Incremental Idler
Why it's similar: Clicker Heroes scratches the same itch as Farmer Against Potatoes Idle: incremental and idler.
How it differs: The big change is the setting: fantasy. It is a 2015 release, older than Farmer Against Potatoes Idle.
Best pick if incremental is what kept you playing Farmer Against Potatoes Idle.