100% match
1. Stardew Valley
2016 · $14.99 · 98% positive · Co-op
Life Sim Pixel Graphics Agriculture Sandbox
Why it's similar: Stardew Valley scratches the same itch as Horsey Game: life sim, pixel graphics and agriculture.
How it differs: It costs more ($14.99 vs $9.99). Unlike Horsey Game, you can play it in co-op.
Best pick if life sim is what kept you playing Horsey Game.