100% match
1. Left 4 Dead 2
2009 · $9.99 · 97% positive · Co-op
Zombies FPS Shooter Horror
Why it's similar: Left 4 Dead 2 scratches the same itch as John Carpenter's Toxic Commando: zombies, fps and shooter.
How it differs: It is cheaper ($9.99 vs $39.99). It swaps the setting for post apocalyptic.
Best pick if zombies is what kept you playing John Carpenter's Toxic Commando.