100% match
1. Undertale
2015 · $9.99 · 96% positive
Multiple Endings Choices Matter Pixel Graphics Psychological Horror
Why it's similar: Undertale scratches the same itch as Matchmaking Inc.: multiple endings, choices matter and pixel graphics.
How it differs: It swaps the setting for horror. It is an older game from 2015.
Start here if the multiple endings in Matchmaking Inc. was your favorite part.