100% match
1. The Sims 4
2020 · Free · 86% positive
Life Sim Character Customization Romance Relaxing
Why it's similar: Players tag The Sims 4 with the same things they love in Moonlight Peaks — life sim, character customization and romance.
How it differs: Unlike Moonlight Peaks, it is free to play. It is a 2020 release, older than Moonlight Peaks.
Best pick if life sim is what kept you playing Moonlight Peaks.