100% match
1. The Room 4: Old Sins
2021 · $8.99 · 98% positive
Puzzle Mystery Point & Click Hidden Object
Why it's similar: The Room 4: Old Sins scratches the same itch as Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem: puzzle, mystery and point & click.
How it differs: At $8.99 it costs less than Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem ($21.99). The big change is the setting: lovecraftian and steampunk.
Start here if the puzzle in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem was your favorite part.