QueuePick

25 Games Like Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem

This list helps you find games similar to Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem, ranked based on shared Steam tags, store description similarity, player signals, and review quality. You can explore titles like The Room 4: Old Sins and The Room Two, which offer engaging puzzles and mystery elements. Other notable picks include The Case of the Golden Idol, perfect for those who enjoy detective stories. Whether you’re looking for a gripping narrative or challenging puzzles, this list has you covered.

Updated November 15, 2026

  1. The Room 4: Old Sins

    100% match

    1. The Room 4: Old Sins

    2021 · $8.99 · 98% positive

    Puzzle Mystery Point & Click Hidden Object

    Why it's similar: The Room 4: Old Sins scratches the same itch as Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem: puzzle, mystery and point & click.

    How it differs: At $8.99 it costs less than Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem ($21.99). The big change is the setting: lovecraftian and steampunk.

    Start here if the puzzle in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem was your favorite part.

    Games like The Room 4: Old Sins View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  2. The Room Two

    90% match

    2. The Room Two

    2016 · $4.99 · 97% positive

    Puzzle Mystery Point & Click Hidden Object

    Why it's similar: Expect puzzle, mystery and point & click, the same ingredients that make Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem work.

    How it differs: At $4.99 it costs less than Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem ($21.99). The big change is the setting: lovecraftian and steampunk.

    Best pick if puzzle is what kept you playing Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like The Room Two View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  3. The Roottrees are Dead

    93% match

    3. The Roottrees are Dead

    2025 · $19.99 · 96% positive

    Detective Mystery Point & Click Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Expect detective, mystery and point & click, the same ingredients that make Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem work.

    How it differs: The camera moves from first person to 2d. It is a newer release (2025).

    Play it if you loved the detective side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like The Roottrees are Dead View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  4. Return of the Obra Dinn

    82% match

    4. Return of the Obra Dinn

    2018 · $19.99 · 96% positive

    Detective Mystery Puzzle Retro

    Why it's similar: Expect detective, mystery and puzzle, the same ingredients that make Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem work.

    How it differs: The big change is the setting: historical and pirates. Steam players rate it even higher (96% positive).

    Play it if you loved the detective side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like Return of the Obra Dinn View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  5. Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc

    81% match

    5. Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc

    2016 · $19.99 · 95% positive

    Detective Mystery Puzzle Point & Click

    Why it's similar: Players tag Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc with the same things they love in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem — detective, mystery and puzzle.

    How it differs: It scores 95% positive on Steam, above Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Best pick if detective is what kept you playing Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

  6. The Case of the Golden Idol

    86% match

    6. The Case of the Golden Idol

    2022 · $17.99 · 98% positive

    Detective Mystery Point & Click Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around detective, mystery and point & click.

    How it differs: It swaps the setting for historical. It plays from a 2d view instead of first person.

    Play it if you loved the detective side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

  7. What Remains of Edith Finch

    80% match

    7. What Remains of Edith Finch

    2017 · $19.99 · 94% positive

    Mystery Exploration Female Protagonist Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Players tag What Remains of Edith Finch with the same things they love in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem — mystery, exploration and female protagonist.

    How it differs: The big change is the setting: lovecraftian. Steam players rate it even higher (94% positive).

    Start here if the mystery in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem was your favorite part.

  8. The House of Da Vinci

    90% match

    8. The House of Da Vinci

    2017 · $19.99 · 81% positive

    Mystery Point & Click Puzzle Exploration

    Why it's similar: The House of Da Vinci scratches the same itch as Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem: mystery, point & click and puzzle.

    How it differs: It swaps the setting for historical and medieval. Steam players rate it even higher (81% positive).

    Play it if you loved the mystery side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like The House of Da Vinci View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  9. Firewatch

    75% match

    9. Firewatch

    2016 · $19.99 · 89% positive

    Mystery Exploration Horror

    Why it's similar: Firewatch shares Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem's focus on mystery, exploration and horror.

    How it differs: It scores 89% positive on Steam, above Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Play it if you loved the mystery side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like Firewatch View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  10. The Wolf Among Us

    78% match

    10. The Wolf Among Us

    2013 · $14.99 · 97% positive

    Detective Point & Click Mystery Dark

    Why it's similar: Expect detective, point & click and mystery, the same ingredients that make Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem work.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($14.99 vs $21.99). It swaps the setting for fantasy.

    Play it if you loved the detective side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

  11. realMyst: Masterpiece Edition

    92% match

    11. realMyst: Masterpiece Edition

    2014 · $17.99 · 88% positive

    Puzzle Point & Click Mystery Exploration

    Why it's similar: Players tag “realMyst: Masterpiece Edition” with the same things they love in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem — puzzle, point & click and mystery.

    How it differs: It is a 2014 release, older than Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem. Steam players rate it even higher (88% positive).

    Start here if the puzzle in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem was your favorite part.

  12. The Incident at Galley House

    87% match

    12. The Incident at Galley House

    2026 · $19.99 · 97% positive

    Mystery Detective Puzzle Horror

    Why it's similar: The Incident at Galley House shares Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem's focus on mystery, detective and puzzle.

    How it differs: It plays from a 2d view instead of first person. It came out more recently, in 2026.

    Best pick if mystery is what kept you playing Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

  13. Tangle Tower

    86% match

    13. Tangle Tower

    2019 · $19.99 · 95% positive

    Detective Point & Click Puzzle Mystery

    Why it's similar: Tangle Tower scratches the same itch as Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem: detective, point & click and puzzle.

    How it differs: It plays from a 2d view instead of first person. It scores 95% positive on Steam, above Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Play it if you loved the detective side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like Tangle Tower View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  14. Kathy Rain: Director's Cut

    91% match

    14. Kathy Rain: Director's Cut

    2021 · $14.99 · 92% positive

    Detective Mystery Point & Click Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Players tag Kathy Rain: Director's Cut with the same things they love in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem — detective, mystery and point & click.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($14.99 vs $21.99). It plays from a 2d view instead of first person.

    Play it if you loved the detective side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

  15. Riven (1997)

    91% match

    15. Riven (1997)

    2010 · $5.99 · 89% positive

    Point & Click Puzzle Exploration Mystery

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around point & click, puzzle and exploration.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($5.99 vs $21.99). It swaps the setting for steampunk and sci fi.

    Best pick if point & click is what kept you playing Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like Riven (1997) View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  16. Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony

    80% match

    16. Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony

    2017 · $39.99 · 88% positive

    Detective Mystery Female Protagonist Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony scratches the same itch as Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem: detective, mystery and female protagonist.

    How it differs: It costs more ($39.99 vs $21.99). It scores 88% positive on Steam, above Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Play it if you loved the detective side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

  17. Strange Horticulture

    79% match

    17. Strange Horticulture

    2022 · $15.99 · 95% positive

    Detective Mystery Point & Click Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Strange Horticulture shares Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem's focus on detective, mystery and point & click.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($15.99 vs $21.99). It swaps the setting for lovecraftian.

    Best pick if detective is what kept you playing Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like Strange Horticulture View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  18. Cube Escape Collection

    88% match

    18. Cube Escape Collection

    2020 · $4.99 · 97% positive

    Point & Click Puzzle Mystery Detective

    Why it's similar: Cube Escape Collection scratches the same itch as Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem: point & click, puzzle and mystery.

    How it differs: At $4.99 it costs less than Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem ($21.99). The camera moves from first person to 2d.

    Start here if the point & click in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem was your favorite part.

    Games like Cube Escape Collection View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  19. Outer Wilds

    71% match

    19. Outer Wilds

    2020 · $24.99 · 95% positive

    Mystery Puzzle Exploration Horror

    Why it's similar: Players tag Outer Wilds with the same things they love in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem — mystery, puzzle and exploration.

    How it differs: It swaps the setting for space and sci fi. It scores 95% positive on Steam, above Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Play it if you loved the mystery side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like Outer Wilds $24.99 at WinGameStore Good match? Thanks!
  20. Agent A: A puzzle in disguise

    87% match

    20. Agent A: A puzzle in disguise

    2019 · $19.99 · 95% positive

    Detective Mystery Point & Click Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Players tag Agent A: A puzzle in disguise with the same things they love in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem — detective, mystery and point & click.

    How it differs: It scores 95% positive on Steam, above Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Play it if you loved the detective side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

  21. Boxes: Lost Fragments

    87% match

    21. Boxes: Lost Fragments

    2024 · $14.99 · 91% positive

    Mystery Point & Click Puzzle Hidden Object

    Why it's similar: Players tag Boxes: Lost Fragments with the same things they love in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem — mystery, point & click and puzzle.

    How it differs: At $14.99 it costs less than Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem ($21.99). It is a newer release (2024).

    Best pick if mystery is what kept you playing Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like Boxes: Lost Fragments View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  22. Myst: Masterpiece Edition

    91% match

    22. Myst: Masterpiece Edition

    2011 · $5.99 · 86% positive

    Point & Click Puzzle Exploration Mystery

    Why it's similar: Players tag Myst: Masterpiece Edition with the same things they love in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem — point & click, puzzle and exploration.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($5.99 vs $21.99). It swaps the setting for steampunk.

    Best pick if point & click is what kept you playing Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like Myst: Masterpiece Edition View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  23. Penelope Pendrick and the Art of Deceit

    94% match

    23. Penelope Pendrick and the Art of Deceit

    2025 · $24.99 · 97% positive

    Mystery Point & Click Puzzle Detective

    Why it's similar: Expect mystery, point & click and puzzle, the same ingredients that make Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem work.

    How it differs: It is a newer release (2025). Steam players rate it even higher (97% positive).

    Start here if the mystery in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem was your favorite part.

    View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  24. The Rise of the Golden Idol

    85% match

    24. The Rise of the Golden Idol

    2024 · $19.99 · 95% positive

    Detective Mystery Puzzle Exploration

    Why it's similar: Players tag The Rise of the Golden Idol with the same things they love in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem — detective, mystery and puzzle.

    How it differs: The big change is the setting: historical. The camera moves from first person to 2d.

    Start here if the detective in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem was your favorite part.

  25. Sally Face - Episode One

    78% match

    25. Sally Face - Episode One

    2016 · $2.99 · 97% positive

    Mystery Puzzle Point & Click Horror

    Why it's similar: Sally Face - Episode One scratches the same itch as Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem: mystery, puzzle and point & click.

    How it differs: At $2.99 it costs less than Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem ($21.99). The camera moves from first person to 2d.

    Play it if you loved the mystery side of Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem.

    Games like Sally Face - Episode One View on Steam Good match? Thanks!

Quick comparison

Game Match Price Co-op Steam rating Year
The Room 4: Old Sins 100% $8.99 No 98% 2021
The Room Two 90% $4.99 No 97% 2016
The Roottrees are Dead 93% $19.99 No 96% 2025
Return of the Obra Dinn 82% $19.99 No 96% 2018
Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc 81% $19.99 No 95% 2016
The Case of the Golden Idol 86% $17.99 No 98% 2022
What Remains of Edith Finch 80% $19.99 No 94% 2017
The House of Da Vinci 90% $19.99 No 81% 2017
Firewatch 75% $19.99 No 89% 2016
The Wolf Among Us 78% $14.99 No 97% 2013
realMyst: Masterpiece Edition 92% $17.99 No 88% 2014
The Incident at Galley House 87% $19.99 No 97% 2026
Tangle Tower 86% $19.99 No 95% 2019
Kathy Rain: Director's Cut 91% $14.99 No 92% 2021
Riven (1997) 91% $5.99 No 89% 2010
Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony 80% $39.99 No 88% 2017
Strange Horticulture 79% $15.99 No 95% 2022
Cube Escape Collection 88% $4.99 No 97% 2020
Outer Wilds 71% $24.99 No 95% 2020
Agent A: A puzzle in disguise 87% $19.99 No 95% 2019
Boxes: Lost Fragments 87% $14.99 No 91% 2024
Myst: Masterpiece Edition 91% $5.99 No 86% 2011
Penelope Pendrick and the Art of Deceit 94% $24.99 No 97% 2025
The Rise of the Golden Idol 85% $19.99 No 95% 2024
Sally Face - Episode One 78% $2.99 No 97% 2016

FAQ

What is the most similar game to Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem?
The Room 4: Old Sins is the closest match, sharing puzzle, mystery and point & click.
Is there a free game like Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem?
None of the closest matches are free to play right now; the cheapest are listed in the table above.
Are there games like Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem with co-op?
Most of the closest matches are single-player.

How we rank: each game is compared on its Steam user tags, store description and player signals, then weighted by review quality. At most two games from the same series appear in one list.