100% match
1. Europa Universalis IV
2013 · $49.99 · 86% positive · Co-op
Grand Strategy Historical 4X Diplomacy
Why it's similar: Players tag Europa Universalis IV with the same things they love in Old World — grand strategy, historical and 4x.
How it differs: It costs more ($49.99 vs $39.99). It is an older game from 2013.
Best pick if grand strategy is what kept you playing Old World.