100% match
1. Cookie Clicker
2021 · $4.99 · 96% positive
Incremental Resource Management Idler Pixel Graphics
Why it's similar: Both games are built around incremental, resource management and idler.
How it differs: At $4.99 it costs less than Orb of Creation ($11.99). The big change is the setting: horror.
Best pick if incremental is what kept you playing Orb of Creation.