100% match
1. Team Fortress 2
2007 · Free · 90% positive · Co-op
Hero Shooter FPS Shooter Team-Based
Why it's similar: Team Fortress 2 scratches the same itch as Paladins: hero shooter, fps and shooter.
How it differs: It is a 2007 release, older than Paladins. It scores 90% positive on Steam, above Paladins.
Start here if the hero shooter in Paladins was your favorite part.