QueuePick

25 Games Like Pony Island

This list helps you find games similar to Pony Island, ranked based on shared Steam tags, store description similarity, player signals, and review quality. Some of the top picks include Undertale, known for its pixel graphics and dark themes, and OneShot, which combines pixel graphics with puzzle elements and psychological horror. Each game offers a unique experience while sharing key features with Pony Island.

Updated November 15, 2026

  1. Undertale

    100% match

    1. Undertale

    2015 · $9.99 · 96% positive

    Pixel Graphics Dark Psychological Horror Horror

    Why it's similar: Expect pixel graphics, dark and psychological horror, the same ingredients that make Pony Island work.

    How it differs: It costs more ($9.99 vs $4.99).

    Play it if you loved the pixel graphics side of Pony Island.

    Games like Undertale View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  2. OneShot

    100% match

    2. OneShot

    2016 · $9.99 · 98% positive

    Pixel Graphics Puzzle Psychological Horror

    Why it's similar: Expect pixel graphics, puzzle and psychological horror, the same ingredients that make Pony Island work.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $9.99 against $4.99 for Pony Island.

    Best pick if pixel graphics is what kept you playing Pony Island.

    Games like OneShot View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  3. Fran Bow

    100% match

    3. Fran Bow

    2015 · $14.99 · 96% positive

    Psychological Horror Puzzle Horror Dark

    Why it's similar: Players tag Fran Bow with the same things they love in Pony Island — psychological horror, puzzle and horror.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $14.99 against $4.99 for Pony Island. It swaps the setting for dark fantasy and fantasy.

    Start here if the psychological horror in Pony Island was your favorite part.

    Games like Fran Bow View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  4. OMORI

    100% match

    4. OMORI

    2020 · $19.99 · 97% positive

    Psychological Horror Pixel Graphics Horror

    Why it's similar: Players tag OMORI with the same things they love in Pony Island — psychological horror, pixel graphics and horror.

    How it differs: It costs more ($19.99 vs $4.99). The big change is the setting: fantasy.

    Start here if the psychological horror in Pony Island was your favorite part.

    Games like OMORI View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  5. Little Nightmares

    100% match

    5. Little Nightmares

    2017 · $19.99 · 94% positive

    Puzzle Horror Dark Psychological Horror

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around puzzle, horror and dark.

    How it differs: It costs more ($19.99 vs $4.99). The camera moves from 2d to third person.

    Play it if you loved the puzzle side of Pony Island.

  6. Papers, Please

    99% match

    6. Papers, Please

    2013 · $9.99 · 97% positive

    Pixel Graphics Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Expect pixel graphics and puzzle, the same ingredients that make Pony Island work.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $9.99 against $4.99 for Pony Island.

    Start here if the pixel graphics in Pony Island was your favorite part.

    Games like Papers, Please View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  7. Sally Face - Episode One

    100% match

    7. Sally Face - Episode One

    2016 · $2.99 · 97% positive

    Psychological Horror Puzzle Horror Dark

    Why it's similar: Players tag Sally Face - Episode One with the same things they love in Pony Island — psychological horror, puzzle and horror.

    How it differs: At $2.99 it costs less than Pony Island ($4.99).

    Play it if you loved the psychological horror side of Pony Island.

    Games like Sally Face - Episode One View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  8. Poppy Playtime

    95% match

    8. Poppy Playtime

    2021 · Free · 88% positive

    Horror Puzzle Dark Psychological Horror

    Why it's similar: Poppy Playtime shares Pony Island's focus on horror, puzzle and dark.

    How it differs: It costs nothing to try — Pony Island does. It plays from a first person view instead of 2d.

    Play it if you loved the horror side of Pony Island.

    Games like Poppy Playtime View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  9. Little Nightmares II

    100% match

    9. Little Nightmares II

    2021 · $29.99 · 93% positive

    Puzzle Horror Dark Psychological Horror

    Why it's similar: Little Nightmares II scratches the same itch as Pony Island: puzzle, horror and dark.

    How it differs: It costs more ($29.99 vs $4.99). It came out more recently, in 2021.

    Start here if the puzzle in Pony Island was your favorite part.

  10. FAITH: The Unholy Trinity

    100% match

    10. FAITH: The Unholy Trinity

    2022 · $14.99 · 94% positive

    Psychological Horror Pixel Graphics Horror Dark

    Why it's similar: Expect psychological horror, pixel graphics and horror, the same ingredients that make Pony Island work.

    How it differs: It costs more ($14.99 vs $4.99). The big change is the setting: lovecraftian.

    Best pick if psychological horror is what kept you playing Pony Island.

    Games like FAITH: The Unholy Trinity View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  11. Bendy and the Ink Machine

    100% match

    11. Bendy and the Ink Machine

    2017 · $19.99 · 88% positive

    Puzzle Horror Dark Psychological Horror

    Why it's similar: Players tag Bendy and the Ink Machine with the same things they love in Pony Island — puzzle, horror and dark.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $19.99 against $4.99 for Pony Island. It plays from a first person view instead of 2d.

    Play it if you loved the puzzle side of Pony Island.

    Games like Bendy and the Ink Machine View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  12. CARRION

    98% match

    12. CARRION

    2020 · $19.99 · 94% positive

    Pixel Graphics Horror Puzzle Gore

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around pixel graphics, horror and puzzle.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $19.99 against $4.99 for Pony Island. It swaps the setting for lovecraftian and sci fi.

    Play it if you loved the pixel graphics side of Pony Island.

    Games like CARRION View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  13. Changed

    100% match

    13. Changed

    2018 · $4.99 · 84% positive

    Psychological Horror Puzzle Pixel Graphics Horror

    Why it's similar: Changed scratches the same itch as Pony Island: psychological horror, puzzle and pixel graphics.

    Start here if the psychological horror in Pony Island was your favorite part.

    Games like Changed View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  14. The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth

    87% match

    14. The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth

    2014 · $14.99 · 96% positive · Co-op

    Pixel Graphics Dark Horror Gore

    Why it's similar: Players tag The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth with the same things they love in Pony Island — pixel graphics, dark and horror.

    How it differs: It costs more ($14.99 vs $4.99). Unlike Pony Island, you can play it in co-op.

    Start here if the pixel graphics in Pony Island was your favorite part.

  15. The Hex

    100% match

    15. The Hex

    2018 · $9.99 · 94% positive

    Psychological Horror Pixel Graphics Dark Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around psychological horror, pixel graphics and dark.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $9.99 against $4.99 for Pony Island.

    Best pick if psychological horror is what kept you playing Pony Island.

    Games like The Hex View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  16. SOMA

    96% match

    16. SOMA

    2015 · $29.99 · 95% positive

    Psychological Horror Puzzle Horror Dark

    Why it's similar: Players tag SOMA with the same things they love in Pony Island — psychological horror, puzzle and horror.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $29.99 against $4.99 for Pony Island. It swaps the setting for lovecraftian and underwater.

    Play it if you loved the psychological horror side of Pony Island.

    Games like SOMA View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  17. Amnesia: The Dark Descent

    100% match

    17. Amnesia: The Dark Descent

    2010 · $19.99 · 95% positive

    Horror Psychological Horror Puzzle Dark

    Why it's similar: Players tag Amnesia: The Dark Descent with the same things they love in Pony Island — horror, psychological horror and puzzle.

    How it differs: It costs more ($19.99 vs $4.99). The big change is the setting: lovecraftian.

    Best pick if horror is what kept you playing Pony Island.

    Games like Amnesia: The Dark Descent View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  18. Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy

    93% match

    18. Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy

    2017 · $7.99 · 84% positive

    Psychological Horror Horror

    Why it's similar: Players tag Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy with the same things they love in Pony Island — psychological horror and horror.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $7.99 against $4.99 for Pony Island. The camera moves from 2d to third person.

    Start here if the psychological horror in Pony Island was your favorite part.

  19. Baba Is You

    98% match

    19. Baba Is You

    2019 · $14.99 · 97% positive

    Puzzle Pixel Graphics

    Why it's similar: Players tag Baba Is You with the same things they love in Pony Island — puzzle and pixel graphics.

    How it differs: It costs more ($14.99 vs $4.99).

    Start here if the puzzle in Pony Island was your favorite part.

    Games like Baba Is You View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  20. Inscryption

    88% match

    20. Inscryption

    2021 · $19.99 · 96% positive

    Puzzle Horror Dark Experimental

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around puzzle, horror and dark.

    How it differs: It costs more ($19.99 vs $4.99). It came out more recently, in 2021.

    Start here if the puzzle in Pony Island was your favorite part.

    Games like Inscryption View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  21. Mouthwashing

    94% match

    21. Mouthwashing

    2024 · $12.99 · 95% positive

    Psychological Horror Horror Dark Gore

    Why it's similar: Mouthwashing shares Pony Island's focus on psychological horror, horror and dark.

    How it differs: It costs more ($12.99 vs $4.99). The big change is the setting: space.

    Best pick if psychological horror is what kept you playing Pony Island.

    Games like Mouthwashing View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  22. ANIMAL WELL

    97% match

    22. ANIMAL WELL

    2024 · $24.99 · 95% positive

    Puzzle Pixel Graphics Horror

    Why it's similar: ANIMAL WELL scratches the same itch as Pony Island: puzzle, pixel graphics and horror.

    How it differs: It costs more ($24.99 vs $4.99). It came out more recently, in 2024.

    Start here if the puzzle in Pony Island was your favorite part.

    Games like ANIMAL WELL View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  23. Outer Wilds

    89% match

    23. Outer Wilds

    2020 · $24.99 · 95% positive

    Puzzle Horror Psychological Horror

    Why it's similar: Outer Wilds shares Pony Island's focus on puzzle, horror and psychological horror.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $24.99 against $4.99 for Pony Island. It swaps the setting for space and sci fi.

    Play it if you loved the puzzle side of Pony Island.

    Games like Outer Wilds $24.99 at WinGameStore Good match? Thanks!
  24. Mad Father

    100% match

    25. Mad Father

    2016 · $9.99 · 98% positive

    Psychological Horror Pixel Graphics Horror Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around psychological horror, pixel graphics and horror.

    How it differs: It costs more ($9.99 vs $4.99).

    Play it if you loved the psychological horror side of Pony Island.

    Games like Mad Father View on Steam Good match? Thanks!

Quick comparison

Game Match Price Co-op Steam rating Year
Undertale 100% $9.99 No 96% 2015
OneShot 100% $9.99 No 98% 2016
Fran Bow 100% $14.99 No 96% 2015
OMORI 100% $19.99 No 97% 2020
Little Nightmares 100% $19.99 No 94% 2017
Papers, Please 99% $9.99 No 97% 2013
Sally Face - Episode One 100% $2.99 No 97% 2016
Poppy Playtime 95% Free No 88% 2021
Little Nightmares II 100% $29.99 No 93% 2021
FAITH: The Unholy Trinity 100% $14.99 No 94% 2022
Bendy and the Ink Machine 100% $19.99 No 88% 2017
CARRION 98% $19.99 No 94% 2020
Changed 100% $4.99 No 84% 2018
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth 87% $14.99 Yes 96% 2014
The Hex 100% $9.99 No 94% 2018
SOMA 96% $29.99 No 95% 2015
Amnesia: The Dark Descent 100% $19.99 No 95% 2010
Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy 93% $7.99 No 84% 2017
Baba Is You 98% $14.99 No 97% 2019
Inscryption 88% $19.99 No 96% 2021
Mouthwashing 94% $12.99 No 95% 2024
ANIMAL WELL 97% $24.99 No 95% 2024
Outer Wilds 89% $24.99 No 95% 2020
There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension 99% $12.99 No 97% 2020
Mad Father 100% $9.99 No 98% 2016

FAQ

What is the most similar game to Pony Island?
Undertale is the closest match, sharing pixel graphics, dark and psychological horror.
Is there a free game like Pony Island?
Yes: Poppy Playtime is free to play.
Are there games like Pony Island with co-op?
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth support co-op.

How we rank: each game is compared on its Steam user tags, store description and player signals, then weighted by review quality. At most two games from the same series appear in one list.