100% match
1. Garry's Mod
2006 · $9.99 · 97% positive
Physics Sandbox Realistic
Why it's similar: Garry's Mod scratches the same itch as Potato Please: physics, sandbox and realistic.
How it differs: It is a 2006 release, older than Potato Please. Steam players rate it even higher (97% positive).
Best pick if physics is what kept you playing Potato Please.