100% match
1. Psychonauts
2006 · $9.99 · 95% positive
Comedy Platformer 3D Platformer Psychological
Why it's similar: Psychonauts shares Psychonauts 2's focus on comedy, platformer and 3d platformer.
How it differs: It is cheaper ($9.99 vs $59.99). It is a 2006 release, older than Psychonauts 2.
Best pick if comedy is what kept you playing Psychonauts 2.