100% match
1. Counter-Strike 2
2012 · Free · 85% positive · Co-op
FPS Shooter Competitive Fast-Paced
Why it's similar: Counter-Strike 2 scratches the same itch as Quake III Arena: fps, shooter and competitive.
How it differs: It costs nothing to try — Quake III Arena does. It adds co-op, so you can bring friends along.
Best pick if fps is what kept you playing Quake III Arena.