100% match
1. Brawlhalla
2017 · Free · 77% positive · Co-op
Fighting 2D Fighter Local Multiplayer Platformer
Why it's similar: Brawlhalla scratches the same itch as Rivals of Aether: fighting, 2d fighter and local multiplayer.
How it differs: Unlike Rivals of Aether, it is free to play. It swaps the setting for fantasy.
Best pick if fighting is what kept you playing Rivals of Aether.