QueuePick

25 Games Like Scarlet Hollow

This list helps you find games similar to Scarlet Hollow, ranked based on shared Steam tags, store description similarity, player signals, and review quality. Among the top picks are Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut, known for its psychological horror and choices matter elements, and The Coffin of Andy and Leyley, which also emphasizes visual novel storytelling and psychological themes. You'll discover a variety of titles that capture the essence of choices and horror, making it easier to find your next favorite.

Updated November 15, 2026

  1. Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut

    100% match

    1. Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut

    2023 · $17.99 · 96% positive

    Choices Matter Visual Novel Psychological Horror Horror

    Why it's similar: Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut scratches the same itch as Scarlet Hollow: choices matter, visual novel and psychological horror.

    How it differs: At $17.99 it costs less than Scarlet Hollow ($29.99).

    Best pick if choices matter is what kept you playing Scarlet Hollow.

  2. The Coffin of Andy and Leyley

    88% match

    2. The Coffin of Andy and Leyley

    2023 · $11.99 · 95% positive

    Visual Novel Psychological Horror Choices Matter Multiple Endings

    Why it's similar: The Coffin of Andy and Leyley shares Scarlet Hollow's focus on visual novel, psychological horror and choices matter.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($11.99 vs $29.99).

    Play it if you loved the visual novel side of Scarlet Hollow.

  3. Who's Lila?

    90% match

    4. Who's Lila?

    2022 · $11.99 · 94% positive

    Visual Novel Horror Psychological Horror Choices Matter

    Why it's similar: Who's Lila? scratches the same itch as Scarlet Hollow: visual novel, horror and psychological horror.

    How it differs: At $11.99 it costs less than Scarlet Hollow ($29.99).

    Best pick if visual novel is what kept you playing Scarlet Hollow.

    Games like Who's Lila? View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  4. The Walking Dead: The Telltale Definitive Series

    79% match

    5. The Walking Dead: The Telltale Definitive Series

    2020 · $49.99 · 97% positive

    Choices Matter Multiple Endings Interactive Fiction Horror

    Why it's similar: The Walking Dead: The Telltale Definitive Series shares Scarlet Hollow's focus on choices matter, multiple endings and interactive fiction.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $49.99 against $29.99 for Scarlet Hollow. It swaps the setting for zombies and post apocalyptic.

    Play it if you loved the choices matter side of Scarlet Hollow.

  5. OMORI

    72% match

    6. OMORI

    2020 · $19.99 · 97% positive

    Psychological Horror Multiple Endings Horror

    Why it's similar: OMORI shares Scarlet Hollow's focus on psychological horror, multiple endings and horror.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($19.99 vs $29.99). It swaps the setting for fantasy.

    Best pick if psychological horror is what kept you playing Scarlet Hollow.

    Games like OMORI View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  6. NEEDY STREAMER OVERLOAD

    77% match

    7. NEEDY STREAMER OVERLOAD

    2022 · $15.99 · 95% positive

    Psychological Horror Visual Novel Multiple Endings Dark Humor

    Why it's similar: NEEDY STREAMER OVERLOAD scratches the same itch as Scarlet Hollow: psychological horror, visual novel and multiple endings.

    How it differs: At $15.99 it costs less than Scarlet Hollow ($29.99).

    Play it if you loved the psychological horror side of Scarlet Hollow.

    Games like NEEDY STREAMER OVERLOAD View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  7. Undertale

    68% match

    8. Undertale

    2015 · $9.99 · 96% positive

    Choices Matter Multiple Endings Psychological Horror Dating Sim

    Why it's similar: Players tag Undertale with the same things they love in Scarlet Hollow — choices matter, multiple endings and psychological horror.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($9.99 vs $29.99). It is an older game from 2015.

    Start here if the choices matter in Scarlet Hollow was your favorite part.

    Games like Undertale View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  8. Cabernet

    90% match

    9. Cabernet

    2025 · $19.99 · 94% positive

    Choices Matter Horror Visual Novel Multiple Endings

    Why it's similar: Expect choices matter, horror and visual novel, the same ingredients that make Scarlet Hollow work.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($19.99 vs $29.99).

    Start here if the choices matter in Scarlet Hollow was your favorite part.

    Games like Cabernet View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  9. Doki Doki Literature Club Plus!

    78% match

    10. Doki Doki Literature Club Plus!

    2021 · $14.99 · 97% positive

    Visual Novel Psychological Horror Dating Sim Multiple Endings

    Why it's similar: Players tag Doki Doki Literature Club Plus! with the same things they love in Scarlet Hollow — visual novel, psychological horror and dating sim.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($14.99 vs $29.99).

    Play it if you loved the visual novel side of Scarlet Hollow.

  10. Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc

    75% match

    11. Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc

    2016 · $19.99 · 95% positive

    Visual Novel Mystery Psychological Horror Horror

    Why it's similar: Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc shares Scarlet Hollow's focus on visual novel, mystery and psychological horror.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($19.99 vs $29.99). It is a 2016 release, older than Scarlet Hollow.

    Play it if you loved the visual novel side of Scarlet Hollow.

  11. Zero Escape: The Nonary Games

    82% match

    12. Zero Escape: The Nonary Games

    2017 · $29.99 · 94% positive

    Visual Novel Choices Matter Multiple Endings Psychological Horror

    Why it's similar: Zero Escape: The Nonary Games scratches the same itch as Scarlet Hollow: visual novel, choices matter and multiple endings.

    How it differs: It swaps the setting for sci fi.

    Start here if the visual novel in Scarlet Hollow was your favorite part.

  12. Sally Face - Episode One

    77% match

    13. Sally Face - Episode One

    2016 · $2.99 · 97% positive

    Psychological Horror Horror Mystery Supernatural

    Why it's similar: Expect psychological horror, horror and mystery, the same ingredients that make Scarlet Hollow work.

    How it differs: At $2.99 it costs less than Scarlet Hollow ($29.99). It is an older game from 2016.

    Play it if you loved the psychological horror side of Scarlet Hollow.

    Games like Sally Face - Episode One View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  13. Sucker for Love: First Date

    85% match

    14. Sucker for Love: First Date

    2022 · $9.99 · 98% positive

    Visual Novel Horror Psychological Horror Dating Sim

    Why it's similar: Sucker for Love: First Date shares Scarlet Hollow's focus on visual novel, horror and psychological horror.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($9.99 vs $29.99).

    Best pick if visual novel is what kept you playing Scarlet Hollow.

  14. Little Misfortune

    79% match

    15. Little Misfortune

    2019 · $19.99 · 90% positive

    Choices Matter Psychological Horror Horror Dark Humor

    Why it's similar: Little Misfortune shares Scarlet Hollow's focus on choices matter, psychological horror and horror.

    How it differs: At $19.99 it costs less than Scarlet Hollow ($29.99).

    Play it if you loved the choices matter side of Scarlet Hollow.

    Games like Little Misfortune View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  15. The NOexistenceN of you AND me

    79% match

    16. The NOexistenceN of you AND me

    2024 · $1.99 · 95% positive

    Visual Novel Psychological Horror Multiple Endings Interactive Fiction

    Why it's similar: The NOexistenceN of you AND me scratches the same itch as Scarlet Hollow: visual novel, psychological horror and multiple endings.

    How it differs: At $1.99 it costs less than Scarlet Hollow ($29.99). The big change is the setting: fantasy.

    Play it if you loved the visual novel side of Scarlet Hollow.

  16. The Wolf Among Us

    73% match

    17. The Wolf Among Us

    2013 · $14.99 · 97% positive

    Choices Matter Visual Novel Multiple Endings Point & Click

    Why it's similar: The Wolf Among Us shares Scarlet Hollow's focus on choices matter, visual novel and multiple endings.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($14.99 vs $29.99). It swaps the setting for fantasy.

    Best pick if choices matter is what kept you playing Scarlet Hollow.

  17. Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk

    74% match

    18. Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk

    2020 · $1.49 · 96% positive

    Visual Novel Psychological Horror Horror Interactive Fiction

    Why it's similar: Expect visual novel, psychological horror and horror, the same ingredients that make Scarlet Hollow work.

    How it differs: At $1.49 it costs less than Scarlet Hollow ($29.99).

    Start here if the visual novel in Scarlet Hollow was your favorite part.

  18. DREDGE

    69% match

    20. DREDGE

    2023 · $39.99 · 96% positive

    Mystery Psychological Horror Lovecraftian Horror

    Why it's similar: Players tag DREDGE with the same things they love in Scarlet Hollow — mystery, psychological horror and lovecraftian.

    How it differs: It costs more ($39.99 vs $29.99).

    Start here if the mystery in Scarlet Hollow was your favorite part.

    Games like DREDGE View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  19. Money for Girls: Amortized

    84% match

    22. Money for Girls: Amortized

    2026 · $15.00 · 98% positive

    Visual Novel Horror Dating Sim Multiple Endings

    Why it's similar: Money for Girls: Amortized scratches the same itch as Scarlet Hollow: visual novel, horror and dating sim.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($15.00 vs $29.99). It is a newer release (2026).

    Best pick if visual novel is what kept you playing Scarlet Hollow.

  20. MiSide

    69% match

    23. MiSide

    2024 · $14.99 · 97% positive

    Psychological Horror Horror

    Why it's similar: Expect psychological horror and horror, the same ingredients that make Scarlet Hollow work.

    How it differs: At $14.99 it costs less than Scarlet Hollow ($29.99).

    Play it if you loved the psychological horror side of Scarlet Hollow.

    Games like MiSide View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  21. Dispatch

    64% match

    24. Dispatch

    2025 · $29.99 · 97% positive

    Choices Matter Choose Your Own Adventure Visual Novel Point & Click

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around choices matter, choose your own adventure and visual novel.

    How it differs: The big change is the setting: superhero.

    Play it if you loved the choices matter side of Scarlet Hollow.

    Games like Dispatch View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  22. Corpse Party (2021)

    83% match

    25. Corpse Party (2021)

    2021 · $19.99 · 90% positive

    Horror Psychological Horror Choices Matter Multiple Endings

    Why it's similar: Corpse Party (2021) shares Scarlet Hollow's focus on horror, psychological horror and choices matter.

    How it differs: It is cheaper ($19.99 vs $29.99).

    Start here if the horror in Scarlet Hollow was your favorite part.

    Games like Corpse Party (2021) View on Steam Good match? Thanks!

Quick comparison

Game Match Price Co-op Steam rating Year
Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut 100% $17.99 No 96% 2023
The Coffin of Andy and Leyley 88% $11.99 No 95% 2023
Disco Elysium - The Final Cut 74% $39.99 No 92% 2019
Who's Lila? 90% $11.99 No 94% 2022
The Walking Dead: The Telltale Definitive Series 79% $49.99 No 97% 2020
OMORI 72% $19.99 No 97% 2020
NEEDY STREAMER OVERLOAD 77% $15.99 No 95% 2022
Undertale 68% $9.99 No 96% 2015
Cabernet 90% $19.99 No 94% 2025
Doki Doki Literature Club Plus! 78% $14.99 No 97% 2021
Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc 75% $19.99 No 95% 2016
Zero Escape: The Nonary Games 82% $29.99 No 94% 2017
Sally Face - Episode One 77% $2.99 No 97% 2016
Sucker for Love: First Date 85% $9.99 No 98% 2022
Little Misfortune 79% $19.99 No 90% 2019
The NOexistenceN of you AND me 79% $1.99 No 95% 2024
The Wolf Among Us 73% $14.99 No 97% 2013
Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk 74% $1.49 No 96% 2020
Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk 76% $8.99 No 97% 2021
DREDGE 69% $39.99 No 96% 2023
The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe 70% $24.99 No 94% 2022
Money for Girls: Amortized 84% $15.00 No 98% 2026
MiSide 69% $14.99 No 97% 2024
Dispatch 64% $29.99 No 97% 2025
Corpse Party (2021) 83% $19.99 No 90% 2021

FAQ

What is the most similar game to Scarlet Hollow?
Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut is the closest match, sharing choices matter, visual novel and psychological horror.
Is there a free game like Scarlet Hollow?
None of the closest matches are free to play right now; the cheapest are listed in the table above.
Are there games like Scarlet Hollow with co-op?
Most of the closest matches are single-player.

How we rank: each game is compared on its Steam user tags, store description and player signals, then weighted by review quality. At most two games from the same series appear in one list.