100% match
1. L.A. Noire
2011 · $19.99 · 83% positive
Detective Crime Open World Mystery
Why it's similar: L.A. Noire scratches the same itch as Sherlock Holmes Chapter One: detective, crime and open world.
How it differs: It is cheaper ($19.99 vs $44.99). It is a 2011 release, older than Sherlock Holmes Chapter One.
Play it if you loved the detective side of Sherlock Holmes Chapter One.