100% match
1. Papers, Please
2013 · $9.99 · 97% positive
Point & Click Multiple Endings Puzzle Choices Matter
Why it's similar: Expect point & click, multiple endings and puzzle, the same ingredients that make That's not my Neighbor work.
How it differs: It costs more ($9.99 vs $2.99). It is a 2013 release, older than That's not my Neighbor.
Best pick if point & click is what kept you playing That's not my Neighbor.