100% match
1. Neverwinter
2013 · Free · 74% positive · Co-op
MMORPG Massively Multiplayer Fantasy Open World
Why it's similar: Both games are built around mmorpg, massively multiplayer and fantasy.
How it differs: Unlike The Lord of the Rings Online, you can play it in co-op. It swaps the setting for zombies.
Best pick if mmorpg is what kept you playing The Lord of the Rings Online.