100% match
1. Outer Wilds
2020 · $24.99 · 95% positive
Puzzle Exploration Open World Mystery
Why it's similar: Outer Wilds scratches the same itch as The Witness: puzzle, exploration and open world.
How it differs: At $24.99 it costs less than The Witness ($39.99). The big change is the setting: space and sci fi.
Play it if you loved the puzzle side of The Witness.