100% match
1. The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth
2014 · $14.99 · 96% positive · Co-op
Pixel Graphics Replay Value Dark Horror
Why it's similar: The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth scratches the same itch as Undertale: pixel graphics, replay value and dark.
How it differs: Expect a higher price: $14.99 against $9.99 for Undertale. It adds co-op, so you can bring friends along.
Start here if the pixel graphics in Undertale was your favorite part.