100% match
1. Realm of the Mad God Exalt
2012 · Free · 80% positive · Co-op
MMORPG Pixel Graphics Roguelike Massively Multiplayer
Why it's similar: Expect mmorpg, pixel graphics and roguelike, the same ingredients that make Born Again work.
How it differs: It is a 2012 release, older than Born Again.
Play it if you loved the mmorpg side of Born Again.