100% match
1. Terraria
2011 · $9.99 · 97% positive · Co-op
Pixel Graphics Exploration Replay Value
Why it's similar: Terraria shares Dome Keeper's focus on pixel graphics, exploration and replay value.
How it differs: It is cheaper ($9.99 vs $17.99). It is a 2011 release, older than Dome Keeper.
Start here if the pixel graphics in Dome Keeper was your favorite part.