100% match
1. Terraria
2011 · $9.99 · 97% positive · Co-op
Open World Survival Craft Survival Pixel Graphics Crafting
Why it's similar: Terraria shares Forager's focus on open world survival craft, survival and pixel graphics.
How it differs: It is cheaper ($9.99 vs $19.99). Unlike Forager, you can play it in co-op.
Best pick if open world survival craft is what kept you playing Forager.