100% match
1. Subnautica
2018 · $29.99 · 96% positive
Survival Horror Underwater Exploration
Why it's similar: Subnautica scratches the same itch as Subnautica 2: survival, horror and underwater.
How it differs: There is no co-op here — it is built for playing alone. It is a 2018 release, older than Subnautica 2.
Start here if the survival in Subnautica 2 was your favorite part.