100% match
1. Tabletop Simulator
2015 · $19.99 · 96% positive · Co-op
Tabletop Board Game Sandbox
Why it's similar: Expect tabletop, board game and sandbox, the same ingredients that make TaleSpire work.
How it differs: At $19.99 it costs less than TaleSpire ($24.99). It is an older game from 2015.
Best pick if tabletop is what kept you playing TaleSpire.