QueuePick

25 Games Like The Painscreek Killings

This list helps you find games similar to The Painscreek Killings, focusing on investigation, mystery, and exploration. The rankings are based on shared Steam tags, store description similarity, player signals, and review quality. Among the top picks, you will find Firewatch, known for its immersive exploration, and What Remains of Edith Finch, which offers a unique narrative experience. Other notable mentions include Outer Wilds, which combines exploration with puzzle elements.

Updated November 15, 2026

  1. Firewatch

    100% match

    1. Firewatch

    2016 · $19.99 · 89% positive

    Mystery Exploration Walking Simulator Open World

    Why it's similar: Expect mystery, exploration and walking simulator, the same ingredients that make The Painscreek Killings work.

    Play it if you loved the mystery side of The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like Firewatch View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  2. What Remains of Edith Finch

    100% match

    2. What Remains of Edith Finch

    2017 · $19.99 · 94% positive

    Walking Simulator Mystery Exploration Female Protagonist

    Why it's similar: Players tag What Remains of Edith Finch with the same things they love in The Painscreek Killings — walking simulator, mystery and exploration.

    How it differs: The big change is the setting: lovecraftian. Steam players rate it even higher (94% positive).

    Best pick if walking simulator is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

  3. Outer Wilds

    95% match

    3. Outer Wilds

    2020 · $24.99 · 95% positive

    Exploration Mystery Puzzle Open World

    Why it's similar: Outer Wilds shares The Painscreek Killings's focus on exploration, mystery and puzzle.

    How it differs: It costs more ($24.99 vs $19.99). The big change is the setting: space and sci fi.

    Start here if the exploration in The Painscreek Killings was your favorite part.

    Games like Outer Wilds $24.99 at WinGameStore Good match? Thanks!
  4. The Vanishing of Ethan Carter

    100% match

    4. The Vanishing of Ethan Carter

    2014 · $19.99 · 86% positive

    Mystery Detective Exploration Walking Simulator

    Why it's similar: Players tag The Vanishing of Ethan Carter with the same things they love in The Painscreek Killings — mystery, detective and exploration.

    How it differs: The big change is the setting: lovecraftian.

    Play it if you loved the mystery side of The Painscreek Killings.

  5. Blue Prince

    96% match

    5. Blue Prince

    2025 · $29.99 · 85% positive

    Mystery Exploration Puzzle Investigation

    Why it's similar: Expect mystery, exploration and puzzle, the same ingredients that make The Painscreek Killings work.

    How it differs: It costs more ($29.99 vs $19.99). It is a newer release (2025).

    Best pick if mystery is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like Blue Prince $26.98 at WinGameStore Good match? Thanks!
  6. Poppy Playtime

    86% match

    6. Poppy Playtime

    2021 · Free · 88% positive

    Horror Puzzle Psychological Horror Mystery

    Why it's similar: Poppy Playtime shares The Painscreek Killings's focus on horror, puzzle and psychological horror.

    How it differs: Unlike The Painscreek Killings, it is free to play.

    Best pick if horror is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like Poppy Playtime View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  7. SOMA

    90% match

    7. SOMA

    2015 · $29.99 · 95% positive

    Exploration Horror Puzzle Walking Simulator

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around exploration, horror and puzzle.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $29.99 against $19.99 for The Painscreek Killings. It swaps the setting for lovecraftian and underwater.

    Start here if the exploration in The Painscreek Killings was your favorite part.

    Games like SOMA View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  8. Phasmophobia

    77% match

    8. Phasmophobia

    2020 · $19.99 · 94% positive · Co-op

    Horror Supernatural Psychological Horror Investigation

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around horror, supernatural and psychological horror.

    How it differs: It adds co-op, so you can bring friends along. It scores 94% positive on Steam, above The Painscreek Killings.

    Play it if you loved the horror side of The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like Phasmophobia View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  9. Return of the Obra Dinn

    90% match

    9. Return of the Obra Dinn

    2018 · $19.99 · 96% positive

    Mystery Detective Puzzle Horror

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around mystery, detective and puzzle.

    How it differs: The big change is the setting: historical and pirates. Steam players rate it even higher (96% positive).

    Best pick if mystery is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like Return of the Obra Dinn View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  10. The Case of the Golden Idol

    96% match

    10. The Case of the Golden Idol

    2022 · $17.99 · 98% positive

    Mystery Investigation Detective Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Expect mystery, investigation and detective, the same ingredients that make The Painscreek Killings work.

    How it differs: It swaps the setting for historical. It plays from a 2d view instead of 3d.

    Play it if you loved the mystery side of The Painscreek Killings.

  11. DREDGE

    86% match

    11. DREDGE

    2023 · $39.99 · 96% positive

    Exploration Mystery Open World Horror

    Why it's similar: Expect exploration, mystery and open world, the same ingredients that make The Painscreek Killings work.

    How it differs: It costs more ($39.99 vs $19.99). The big change is the setting: lovecraftian.

    Play it if you loved the exploration side of The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like DREDGE View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  12. INFRA

    100% match

    12. INFRA

    2016 · $29.99 · 87% positive

    Exploration Puzzle Mystery Walking Simulator

    Why it's similar: INFRA scratches the same itch as The Painscreek Killings: exploration, puzzle and mystery.

    How it differs: It costs more ($29.99 vs $19.99).

    Best pick if exploration is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like INFRA View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  13. The Mortuary Assistant

    95% match

    13. The Mortuary Assistant

    2022 · $24.99 · 92% positive

    Horror Supernatural Mystery Exploration

    Why it's similar: Players tag The Mortuary Assistant with the same things they love in The Painscreek Killings — horror, supernatural and mystery.

    How it differs: It costs more ($24.99 vs $19.99). It is a newer release (2022).

    Best pick if horror is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like The Mortuary Assistant View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  14. The Séance of Blake Manor

    96% match

    14. The Séance of Blake Manor

    2025 · $19.99 · 94% positive

    Detective Mystery Puzzle Investigation

    Why it's similar: The Séance of Blake Manor shares The Painscreek Killings's focus on detective, mystery and puzzle.

    How it differs: It swaps the setting for mythology and historical. It is a newer release (2025).

    Best pick if detective is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

  15. The Room 4: Old Sins

    90% match

    15. The Room 4: Old Sins

    2021 · $8.99 · 98% positive

    Puzzle Mystery Horror Exploration

    Why it's similar: Expect puzzle, mystery and horror, the same ingredients that make The Painscreek Killings work.

    How it differs: At $8.99 it costs less than The Painscreek Killings ($19.99). The big change is the setting: lovecraftian and steampunk.

    Start here if the puzzle in The Painscreek Killings was your favorite part.

    Games like The Room 4: Old Sins View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  16. Scene Investigators

    100% match

    16. Scene Investigators

    2023 · $24.99 · 74% positive

    Investigation Detective Mystery Puzzle

    Why it's similar: Scene Investigators shares The Painscreek Killings's focus on investigation, detective and mystery.

    How it differs: It costs more ($24.99 vs $19.99). The big change is the setting: futuristic.

    Start here if the investigation in The Painscreek Killings was your favorite part.

    View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  17. The Forest

    75% match

    17. The Forest

    2018 · $19.99 · 95% positive · Co-op

    Horror Open World Exploration Realistic

    Why it's similar: Players tag The Forest with the same things they love in The Painscreek Killings — horror, open world and exploration.

    How it differs: Unlike The Painscreek Killings, you can play it in co-op. It swaps the setting for zombies.

    Play it if you loved the horror side of The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like The Forest View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  18. The Witness

    89% match

    18. The Witness

    2016 · $39.99 · 82% positive

    Puzzle Exploration Open World Walking Simulator

    Why it's similar: The Witness scratches the same itch as The Painscreek Killings: puzzle, exploration and open world.

    How it differs: Expect a higher price: $39.99 against $19.99 for The Painscreek Killings.

    Play it if you loved the puzzle side of The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like The Witness View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  19. Quern - Undying Thoughts

    96% match

    19. Quern - Undying Thoughts

    2016 · $24.99 · 90% positive

    Mystery Exploration Puzzle Investigation

    Why it's similar: Expect mystery, exploration and puzzle, the same ingredients that make The Painscreek Killings work.

    How it differs: It costs more ($24.99 vs $19.99). The big change is the setting: steampunk.

    Play it if you loved the mystery side of The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like Quern - Undying Thoughts View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  20. The Roottrees are Dead

    91% match

    20. The Roottrees are Dead

    2025 · $19.99 · 96% positive

    Mystery Detective Puzzle Investigation

    Why it's similar: Both games are built around mystery, detective and puzzle.

    How it differs: The camera moves from 3d to 2d. It came out more recently, in 2025.

    Play it if you loved the mystery side of The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like The Roottrees are Dead View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  21. Riven

    97% match

    21. Riven

    2024 · $34.99 · 92% positive

    Exploration Puzzle Mystery Walking Simulator

    Why it's similar: Expect exploration, puzzle and mystery, the same ingredients that make The Painscreek Killings work.

    How it differs: It costs more ($34.99 vs $19.99). It came out more recently, in 2024.

    Best pick if exploration is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like Riven View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  22. Mouthwashing

    83% match

    22. Mouthwashing

    2024 · $12.99 · 95% positive

    Horror Walking Simulator Mystery Thriller

    Why it's similar: Expect horror, walking simulator and mystery, the same ingredients that make The Painscreek Killings work.

    How it differs: At $12.99 it costs less than The Painscreek Killings ($19.99). The big change is the setting: space.

    Play it if you loved the horror side of The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like Mouthwashing View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  23. The Exit 8

    91% match

    23. The Exit 8

    2023 · $3.99 · 93% positive

    Exploration Puzzle Horror Walking Simulator

    Why it's similar: The Exit 8 shares The Painscreek Killings's focus on exploration, puzzle and horror.

    How it differs: At $3.99 it costs less than The Painscreek Killings ($19.99). It is a newer release (2023).

    Best pick if exploration is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like The Exit 8 View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  24. The Room Two

    87% match

    24. The Room Two

    2016 · $4.99 · 97% positive

    Puzzle Mystery Horror Psychological Horror

    Why it's similar: Expect puzzle, mystery and horror, the same ingredients that make The Painscreek Killings work.

    How it differs: At $4.99 it costs less than The Painscreek Killings ($19.99). The big change is the setting: lovecraftian and steampunk.

    Play it if you loved the puzzle side of The Painscreek Killings.

    Games like The Room Two View on Steam Good match? Thanks!
  25. The Rise of the Golden Idol

    95% match

    25. The Rise of the Golden Idol

    2024 · $19.99 · 95% positive

    Mystery Investigation Detective Puzzle

    Why it's similar: The Rise of the Golden Idol scratches the same itch as The Painscreek Killings: mystery, investigation and detective.

    How it differs: The big change is the setting: historical. The camera moves from 3d to 2d.

    Best pick if mystery is what kept you playing The Painscreek Killings.

Quick comparison

Game Match Price Co-op Steam rating Year
Firewatch 100% $19.99 No 89% 2016
What Remains of Edith Finch 100% $19.99 No 94% 2017
Outer Wilds 95% $24.99 No 95% 2020
The Vanishing of Ethan Carter 100% $19.99 No 86% 2014
Blue Prince 96% $29.99 No 85% 2025
Poppy Playtime 86% Free No 88% 2021
SOMA 90% $29.99 No 95% 2015
Phasmophobia 77% $19.99 Yes 94% 2020
Return of the Obra Dinn 90% $19.99 No 96% 2018
The Case of the Golden Idol 96% $17.99 No 98% 2022
DREDGE 86% $39.99 No 96% 2023
INFRA 100% $29.99 No 87% 2016
The Mortuary Assistant 95% $24.99 No 92% 2022
The Séance of Blake Manor 96% $19.99 No 94% 2025
The Room 4: Old Sins 90% $8.99 No 98% 2021
Scene Investigators 100% $24.99 No 74% 2023
The Forest 75% $19.99 Yes 95% 2018
The Witness 89% $39.99 No 82% 2016
Quern - Undying Thoughts 96% $24.99 No 90% 2016
The Roottrees are Dead 91% $19.99 No 96% 2025
Riven 97% $34.99 No 92% 2024
Mouthwashing 83% $12.99 No 95% 2024
The Exit 8 91% $3.99 No 93% 2023
The Room Two 87% $4.99 No 97% 2016
The Rise of the Golden Idol 95% $19.99 No 95% 2024

FAQ

What is the most similar game to The Painscreek Killings?
Firewatch is the closest match, sharing mystery, exploration and walking simulator.
Is there a free game like The Painscreek Killings?
Yes: Poppy Playtime is free to play.
Are there games like The Painscreek Killings with co-op?
Phasmophobia and The Forest support co-op.

How we rank: each game is compared on its Steam user tags, store description and player signals, then weighted by review quality. At most two games from the same series appear in one list.