QueuePick

Best Mystery Games

If you're looking for the best mystery games, this list highlights top picks based on their strong player tags, Steam review quality, and popularity. You can explore titles like Persona 4 Golden, which offers a blend of JRPG elements and anime storytelling, and Outer Wilds, known for its unique exploration and puzzle-solving mechanics. DREDGE, a recent entry, combines fishing with Lovecraftian themes. This ranking helps you find games that not only captivate with their mysteries but also resonate well with players.

Updated November 11, 2026

  1. Persona 4 Golden

    1. Persona 4 Golden

    2020 · $19.99 · 97% positive

    JRPG Anime Turn-Based Combat

    A coming of age story that sets the protagonist and his friends on a journey kickstarted by a chain of serial murders.

    Games like Persona 4 Golden

  2. Outer Wilds

    2. Outer Wilds

    2020 · $24.99 · 95% positive

    Exploration Space Puzzle

    Named Game of the Year 2019 by Giant Bomb, Polygon, Eurogamer, and The Guardian, Outer Wilds is a critically-acclaimed and award-winning open world mystery about a solar system trapped in an endless time loop.

    Games like Outer Wilds Steam Deck: Verified

  3. DREDGE

    3. DREDGE

    2023 · $39.99 · 96% positive

    Exploration Fishing Lovecraftian

    DREDGE is a single-player fishing adventure with a sinister undercurrent. Sell your catch, upgrade your boat, and dredge the depths for long-buried secrets. Explore a mysterious archipelago and discover why some things a...

    Games like DREDGE Steam Deck: Verified

  4. Persona 3 Reload

    4. Persona 3 Reload

    2024 · $59.99 · 96% positive

    JRPG Anime Party-Based RPG

    Dive into the Dark Hour and awaken the depths of your heart. Persona 3 Reload is a captivating reimagining of the genre-defining RPG, reborn for the modern era with cutting-edge graphics and gameplay.

    Games like Persona 3 Reload

  5. Firewatch

    5. Firewatch

    2016 · $19.99 · 89% positive

    Walking Simulator Exploration Open World

    Firewatch is a single-player first-person mystery set in the Wyoming wilderness, where your only emotional lifeline is the person on the other end of a handheld radio.

    Games like Firewatch

  6. Big Walk

    6. Big Walk

    2026 · $19.99 · 94% positive

    Co-op Campaign Puzzle Exploration

    Hang out and get lost with close friends in a big world. A cooperative online walker-talker from the creators of Untitled Goose Game.

    Games like Big Walk Steam Deck: Verified

  7. SIGNALIS

    7. SIGNALIS

    2022 · $19.99 · 96% positive

    Survival Horror Psychological Horror Female Protagonist

    A classic survival horror experience set in a dystopian future where humanity has uncovered a dark secret. Unravel a cosmic mystery, escape terrifying creatures, and scavenge an off-world government facility as Elster, a...

    Games like SIGNALIS

  8. Tactical Breach Wizards

    11. Tactical Breach Wizards

    2024 · $19.99 · 97% positive

    Turn-Based Tactics Puzzle Turn-Based Strategy

    In Tactical Breach Wizards, you lead a team of renegade wizards in kevlar through turn-based battles to unravel a modern conspiracy plot. Combine their unique spells in clever ways, or rewind time to try every crazy plan...

    Games like Tactical Breach Wizards

  9. The Room Two

    12. The Room Two

    2016 · $4.99 · 97% positive

    Puzzle Point & Click Hidden Object

    Unique events transport you to the halls of a long-forgotten crypt. The only means of escape lies locked within a stone pedestal, along with a note from your mysterious ally. His words promise assistance, but only serve...

    Games like The Room Two

  10. The Room 4: Old Sins

    14. The Room 4: Old Sins

    2021 · $8.99 · 98% positive

    Puzzle Point & Click Lovecraftian

    The disappearance of an ambitious engineer and his high-society wife provokes a hunt for a precious artefact. The trail leads you to the attic of their home, and the discovery of an old, peculiar dollhouse. What secrets...

    Games like The Room 4: Old Sins

  11. ANIMAL WELL

    15. ANIMAL WELL

    2024 · $24.99 · 95% positive

    Metroidvania Exploration Puzzle

    Explore a dense, interconnected labyrinth, and unravel its many secrets. Collect items to manipulate your environment in surprising and meaningful ways. Encounter beautiful and unsettling creatures, as you attempt to sur...

    Games like ANIMAL WELL Steam Deck: Verified

  12. Sally Face - Episode One

    16. Sally Face - Episode One

    2016 · $2.99 · 97% positive

    Psychological Horror Horror Dark

    An unsettling adventure following a boy with a prosthetic face. After a string of mysterious murders, Sal and his three friends discover something truly sinister casting shadows over their small town.

    Games like Sally Face - Episode One

  13. Night in the Woods

    17. Night in the Woods

    2017 · $19.99 · 94% positive

    Dark Humor Stylized Exploration

    NIGHT IN THE WOODS is an adventure game focused on exploration, story, and character, featuring dozens of characters to meet and lots to do across a lush, vibrant world.

    Games like Night in the Woods

  14. Strange Horticulture

    18. Strange Horticulture

    2022 · $15.99 · 95% positive

    Puzzle Cozy Dark

    Strange Horticulture is an occult puzzle game in which you play as the proprietor of a local plant store. Find and identify new plants, pet your cat, speak to a coven, or join a cult. Use your collection of powerful plan...

    Games like Strange Horticulture

  15. The Case of the Golden Idol

    19. The Case of the Golden Idol

    2022 · $17.99 · 98% positive

    Detective Investigation Puzzle

    A new kind of detective game that allows you to think and investigate freely. Discover clues surrounding 12 strange and gruesome deaths and build your own theory. Pick your suspect, deduce the motive, unmask the awful tr...

    Games like The Case of the Golden Idol

  16. Town of Salem

    20. Town of Salem

    2014 · $4.99 · 87% positive

    Social Deduction Werewolves Survival

    Inspired by the party games Werewolf and Mafia, Town of Salem is a game of murder, mystery and deception.

    Games like Town of Salem

  17. Scarlet Hollow

    22. Scarlet Hollow

    2021 · $29.99 · 98% positive

    Choices Matter Visual Novel Horror

    Your aunt’s dead, your cousin hates you, and you’re stuck in the dead-end town of Scarlet Hollow. Choose your path through a branching narrative so dense that you'll see less than 1/5 of the game on a single playthrough....

    Games like Scarlet Hollow

  18. The Room Three

    24. The Room Three

    2018 · $5.99 · 95% positive

    Puzzle Point & Click Hidden Object

    Lured to a remote island, you find yourself confined within the rooms of an ominous mansion. You must draw upon all your puzzle-solving ability to navigate a series of trials devised by a mysterious figure known only as...

    Games like The Room Three

  19. The Roottrees are Dead

    25. The Roottrees are Dead

    2025 · $19.99 · 96% positive

    Detective Puzzle Point & Click

    A genealogical mystery straight out of 1998. Scour the early Internet for clues, uncover hidden connections, and piece together the family tree behind the secretive Roottree Corporation.

    Games like The Roottrees are Dead

  20. 1000xRESIST

    26. 1000xRESIST

    2024 · $19.99 · 96% positive

    Female Protagonist Thriller Futuristic

    1000xRESIST is a thrilling sci-fi adventure. The year is unknown, and a disease spread by an alien invasion keeps you underground. You are Watcher. You dutifully fulfil your purpose in serving the ALLMOTHER, until the da...

    Games like 1000xRESIST

  21. A Plague Tale: Requiem

    27. A Plague Tale: Requiem

    2022 · $49.99 · 91% positive

    Action-Adventure Cinematic Exploration

    Embark on a heartrending journey into a brutal, breathtaking world, and discover the cost of saving those you love in a desperate struggle for survival. Strike from the shadows or unleash hell with a variety of weapons,...

    Games like A Plague Tale: Requiem

  22. The Drifter

    28. The Drifter

    2025 · $19.99 · 97% positive

    Point & Click Pixel Graphics Investigation

    A Pulp Adventure Thriller - A murdered drifter awakens. Alive again, seconds before his death. Hunted and haunted, help him untangle a mad web of conspiracy in this fast-paced point 'n click thrill-ride.

    Games like The Drifter

  23. Pentiment

    29. Pentiment

    2022 · $19.99 · 94% positive

    Historical Investigation Interactive Fiction

    Step into a living illustrated world in a time when Europe is at a crossroads of great religious and political change. Walk in the footsteps of Andreas Maler, a master artist who finds himself in the middle of murders, s...

    Games like Pentiment

  24. We Were Here Forever

    30. We Were Here Forever

    2022 · $17.99 · 93% positive

    Puzzle Escape Room Co-op Campaign

    You both awaken imprisoned inside the sinister Castle Rock - were you betrayed, or simply not that clever? Find out in the greatest co-op puzzle adventure in the We Were Here Series! Do you and your partner have what it...

    Games like We Were Here Forever

Related tags

How we rank: a game is listed when Steam players vote Mystery as one of its strongest tags. The list is ordered by review quality (70%) and popularity (30%).