100% match
1. Phasmophobia
2020 · $19.99 · 94% positive · Co-op
Horror Psychological Horror Thriller
Why it's similar: Phasmophobia scratches the same itch as Fears to Fathom - Scratch Creek: horror, psychological horror and thriller.
How it differs: It costs more ($19.99 vs $7.99). It is an older game from 2020.
Play it if you loved the horror side of Fears to Fathom - Scratch Creek.