100% match
1. Undertale
2015 · $9.99 · 96% positive
Pixel Graphics Choices Matter Retro
Why it's similar: Undertale scratches the same itch as Punch Club: pixel graphics, choices matter and retro.
How it differs: The big change is the setting: horror. It scores 96% positive on Steam, above Punch Club.
Play it if you loved the pixel graphics side of Punch Club.