100% match
1. Terraria
2011 · $9.99 · 97% positive · Co-op
Survival Pixel Graphics Open World Survival Craft Sandbox
Why it's similar: Both games are built around survival, pixel graphics and open world survival craft.
How it differs: At $9.99 it costs less than Romestead ($13.99). It is an older game from 2011.
Start here if the survival in Romestead was your favorite part.