100% match
1. Phasmophobia
2020 · $19.99 · 94% positive · Co-op
Horror Psychological Horror Investigation Detective
Why it's similar: Players tag Phasmophobia with the same things they love in Shift At Midnight — horror, psychological horror and investigation.
How it differs: Expect a higher price: $19.99 against $9.99 for Shift At Midnight. It is an older game from 2020.
Play it if you loved the horror side of Shift At Midnight.