100% match
1. Guild Wars 2
2022 · Free · 88% positive · Co-op
MMORPG Character Customization Fantasy Massively Multiplayer
Why it's similar: Guild Wars 2 shares Villagers and Heroes's focus on mmorpg, character customization and fantasy.
How it differs: It is a newer release (2022). It scores 88% positive on Steam, above Villagers and Heroes.
Best pick if mmorpg is what kept you playing Villagers and Heroes.